It has been a
while since the Reserve Bank of India introduced the concept of Base Rate. This
wassupposed to bring in transparency in a market where the determination of
lending rates was opaque and arbitrary. It looks like the Base Rate is not
achieving much, and the banks are merrily continuing in their old ways, albeit
in a new garb.
Previously every
bank had its BPLR or "Base Prime Lending Rate" which was different for each
category of loan. Say you were taking a housing loan from PNB, you would be
offered the loan at, say, PNB Housing Loan BPLR (13%) less an arbitrarily fixed
delta, say in this case 3%, making the floating rate 10% for you. Other loans
would have a different PLR, and a different delta. Ditto for every other bank,
each of whom had their own Base Rates.
What happened when
RBI raised the interest rates by increasing the Repo rate by 0.5%? The bank
would promptly reset its housing loan BPLR to 13.5% and send all its housing
loan customers a letter informing them about the reset interest rate based on
the formula "BPLR plus delta". In this case your rate would rise to 10.5% (BPLR
of 13.5% less 3% which is fixed for your housing loan). What happened to new
customers? Ideally, the bank would have liked to raise the rate for new
customers as well, but competition being fierce in the housing loan market, it
would be unable to do so. So the new customer would be offered the housing at
BPLR less a delta of 3.5%, which is to say, at 10%!
RBI would keep
raising the interest rates, and you would keep getting letters from the bank.
Most borrowers would not even read their letters, or if they did, ignore them,
since the implications are too hard to contemplate. Since the EMI's would not go
up, people would not feel the immediate pinch. However, what actually happens in
such a case is that the tenure of the loan keeps inching up – I know of cases
where the loan tenure went up from 15 years to 25 years!
One fine day, you
the borrower would realize that another bank is willing to take over the loan at
2.5% lower than what you are paying, and you would approach your bank for
prepayment, willing even to pay the 2% prepayment charge that was a standard
part of any housing loan. This was when your bank would wake up and offer to
reduce the interest rate on your loan by a like amount. For the banks, this is
of course a far better strategy than to offer across-the-board reductions as and
when the rates fall.
RBI realized that
the "BPLR" was not serving any purpose since most loans were being lent below
BPLR, and that there was no transparency in changes effected to interest rates
when benchmark rates were revised. So in July 2010, the BPLR was replaced by
the Base Rate. The Base Rate, which each bank fixes, is a rate determined taking
into account its cost of funds and other factors like cost of operations, CRR
and non-performing assets. This was supposed to usher in an era of
transparency, though as to how, no one really specified.
The recent
reduction in Repo rate by 0.5%, coupled with the CRR reduction that was
announced before that is a good time to test what is happening. Most banks have
not reduced their Base Rate at all (which says a lot about "transmission of
monetary policy"!). SBI, among the couple who did, reduced its rates, but not as
expected, by resetting the Base Rate, nor by effecting an across the board
reduction in the "deltas". It has announced that it has cut the rates for auto
loans and SME loans (loans given to small and medium enterprises).
This raises
several questions. How do we know that the rates are actually cut, given that
the deltas could be different for different customers, and different again for
new customers? Why has the rate not been cut for other loans? If rates could be
arbitrarily reduced for some loans, in future they could of course be increased
in the same fashion. What is the guarantee that old customers are not getting
cheated the same way as in the past, i.e., by new customers getting lower
deltas? As to the answers, it is quite obvious – the system is not really
interested in transparency – the old game continues in spite of the change in
nomenclature.
How is it in other
countries? In the US, all consumer and retail loans are linked to the prime
lending rate, and the corporate loans are linked to the London Interbank
Offered rate (Libor). In the UK, the Bank of England's base rate is the
benchmark for consumer and retail loans, while for commercial loans it is the
Libor. The Indian counterpart of Libor is the Mibor (Mumbai Interbank Offered
Rate) which is an overnight rate – there are no three-month or six-month rates
yet. Developing that, and making banks use those rates as benchmark rates for
all loans, is a long way away!
If you have any
loans, whether a housing loan or a personal loan which you had obtained a year
or two back, just check what the newer customers have got. If you find that
they are getting cheaper rates, you can approach your bank to get your interest
rates reduced. They may do it, or they may not; but if they do it, it will be
only after a lot of effort on your part, something that will prevent you from
trying it too often.
One good thing is
that RBI has done away with prepayment charges on housing loans. This makes it
easier to negotiate when it comes to housing loans, but for other loans where
prepayment charges are usually to the order of 4%, even prepayment may not be a
real option.
There was a brief
period (in the years 2001, 2002) when interest rates had hit a low. Housing
loans were available at 7.5-8%. Strangely fixed rate loans were also available
at the same rate. A situation of low interest rates coupled with no fixed rate
premium was brilliant for obtaining fixed rate loans. Those who obtained fixed
rate loans or converted their existing loans to fixed rate loans, are the
happiest lot! Unfortunately, the situation today is that rates are quite high,
and the fixed rate premium on housing loans is about 2%, making it a bad idea to
take fixed rate loans. However, keep watching the market. It is possible that
you could get a brief window where going in for fixed rate loans make sense. You
can pay an additional charge and convert.
Currently, if you
are in the market for loans, the best loan to take is a housing loan. The terms
of repayment are good, and the interest rates are the lowest among retail loans.
There is also another loan called "Loan against property" which has higher
interest rates, and not-so-good prepayment terms, etc. but to me that looks the
next best option, along with gold loans. When you are taking a loan you should
also ask the bank about the option where a savings account with checkbook is
linked to the loan account, and the interest that is charged is on the net
balance (loan less balance in "attached account"). This will enable you to in
effect earn the same interest rates on your savings as that of the loan.
By